Industry leaders urged MPs to leave environmental reviews solely to the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission, while facing questions over foreign enriched uranium and rising battery storage economics.
OTTAWA — Nuclear industry leaders are urging Ottawa to strip overlapping federal environmental reviews from nuclear projects, even as MPs question whether Canada’s push toward small modular reactors leaves the country dependent on foreign enriched fuel and vulnerable to cheaper renewable storage.
During testimony before the House of Commons Standing Committee on Natural Resources on Monday, November 16, 2026, Bruce Power vice-president Pat Dalzell argued that duplicating reviews already conducted by the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission (CNSC) slows projects without improving safety.
“The issue is not safety, the issue is duplication,” Dalzell told the committee, pointing to a Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters report released the same day projecting massive economic returns from four planned Ontario nuclear projects—Darlington’s SMRs, Pickering’s refurbishment, Bruce C, and Wesleyville.
“Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters report being released this week finds that the four nuclear projects planned in Ontario contribute $882 billion in GDP and 3.45 million jobs here across Canada,” Dalzell said, adding those builds would require up to one million tonnes of Canadian steel.
Impact Assessment Act Under Fire
Conservative MP Jeremy Patzer seized on Dalzell’s criticism of overlapping reviews, pointing to an October 9 Alberta Court of Appeal ruling that struck down 2024 federal changes to the Impact Assessment Act as unconstitutional.
“The Alberta Court of Appeal ruled on October 9th that the 2024 legislative modifications failed to fix the core constitutional flaws previously identified by the Supreme Court of Canada and you had mentioned in your opening remarks issues with the Impact Assessment Act in regards to duplicity and I’m just wondering,” Patzer said.
“Some of the delays that possibly could have come from the duplication for the process taking longer, what kind of impact has that had on any projects or potential future projects for Bruce Power and what would you say if this isn’t changed. What is the potential that could be lost going forward if these changes are not made?” Patzer asked.
Dalzell stopped short of weighing in on constitutional law, but urged MPs to leave impact assessments strictly under the CNSC.
“The solution as we’ve recommended it here of having the life cycle regulator really oversee the whole process from start to finish including the impact assessment. We think that is the right way to avoid some of those challenges so without getting into the legality of the previous version of legislation.
I would say that the CNSC as the life cycle regulator and doing the oversight and the decisions around the impact assessment for nuclear sites, to us is the right way for this to have been shaped and we’ve been pretty consistent on our view that they being the experts in the nuclear field, that ultimately helps streamline the whole process. Making sure that the folks most informed about our industry and what we do and have the history of our impact on this site and understand what we report out on helps reduce some of those duplicated processes and make the outcome the best for the people of Canada and our industry,” Dalzell replied.
Asked earlier by Conservative MP Carol Anstey whether regulatory barriers had stalled new Canadian reactors for more than two decades, Conexus Nuclear CEO Rachna Clavero said weak electricity demand—not regulators—was the historic culprit.
“So I don’t know if I would say regulatory barriers were the reason we haven’t had demand in Canada. I think demand has been the reason it hasn’t been there and demand is changing which is why we’re looking at new reactors,” Clavero told Anstey.
Enriched Uranium Questions and Energy Competition
Anstey also questioned Canada’s lack of domestic uranium enrichment facilities as utilities pivot from natural-uranium CANDU reactors toward small modular reactors requiring enriched fuel.
“I would like to ask you as well uranium enrichment. As we move towards developing new technologies that are going to require this enriched fuel and you talked about supply chains, what would it take to establish a supply chain in your opinion?” Anstey asked.
Clavero noted that “98% of our supply chain is here” for existing CANDU operations, while past reviews found domestic enrichment uneconomic. “Enrichment requires processing facilities so there would need to be a detailed benefit cost assessment,” she replied. “In the past we have done that and found its not viable for Canada. However we would need to look at it again and the decision around technology are most important decisions to decide.”
Patzer pressed Clavero further on fuel sourcing: “You had a response to my colleague on SMRs on enriched fuel saying you had secured the fuel for your reactor. Where did you get that from?”
Clavero clarified it was Ontario Power Generation that secured fuel for its BWRX-300 project at Darlington. Meanwhile, Polytechnique Montréal SLOWPOKE-2 reactor manager Darren Hall told Patzer his research reactor converted to low-enriched uranium in 1997 and promised to check the fuel’s origin.
Amid Liberal MP John-Paul Danko’s framing of Budget 2026’s $6.5-billion nuclear commitment as tied to broader electrification, Bloc Québécois MP Mario Simard challenged Polytechnique Montréal’s Nicolas Godbout on whether Ottawa’s 2035 and 2050 reactor timelines are realistic—and whether rising battery storage could undercut nuclear economics.
“From a technical standpoint and I understand your field of expertise is nuclear, but from the technical standpoint do you believe over the next few years given the storage capability that are constantly increasing, do you think that intermittent energy generation, whether it be solar or wind which is far less costly, won’t there be a point of rupture where it might make more sense to move towards these intermittent energies because the storage capabilities is increasing?” Simard asked.
Godbout called the 25-year reactor target realistic, while agreeing to table a Polytechnique Energy Institute study examining how nuclear power stacks up against grid-scale storage. “Studying conducted by our Energy Institute at Polytechnique have indicated nuclear energy is competing with large scale storage. So it’s a very relevant question,” Godbout said.
Separately, Organization of Canadian Nuclear Industries CEO Ivette Vera-Perez urged Ottawa to fund a national supply-chain assessment and targeted supplier grants, noting Canada’s nuclear sector already supports roughly 89,000 jobs and $22 billion in annual economic activity.
As Parliament weighs sweeping legislative changes to hand sole nuclear review authority to the CNSC, Monday’s testimony underscored the central tension behind Canada’s nuclear expansion: an industry pressing for faster approvals and billions in public backing, even as critical questions over fuel independence, cost competitiveness, and long-term waste remain unresolved.