Committee members slam missing departmental briefings as investors and First Nations flag major funding gaps.
OTTAWA — Hours before facing a tight deadline to draft amendments to Bill C-39, opposition MPs had still not received a part-by-part departmental breakdown promised by cabinet ministers two weeks earlier—fuelling broader warnings from business and Indigenous witnesses that the bill’s flagship promises risk collapsing on execution.
The warning unfolded at the House of Commons Legislative Committee on Bill C-39 in Ottawa on Tuesday, November 3, 2026.
Introduced by Prime Minister Mark Carney’s government on September 21, 2026, Bill C-39—the Building Canada Strong Act—bundles over 300 clauses across more than a dozen federal statutes to fast-track major infrastructure approvals, modernize trade corridors and overhaul labour laws. While the government casts the bill as vital to economic security and attracting global investment, it has drawn nationwide protests and intense opposition from labour unions, Indigenous nations, environmental advocates and scientists.
Missing Departmental Analysis
Moments before adjournment, Bloc Québécois MP Gabriel Ste-Marie used his final turn to confront Chair James Maloney and the committee clerk, reminding them that Ministers Steven MacKinnon and Dominic LeBlanc had committed at an October 19 meeting to deliver an explanatory analysis within a week.
“My concern is that we have until tomorrow to submit amendments, and we still haven’t received a document from the departments that explains, part by part, everything that the bill entails. That complicates our work. If the government wants to proceed within tight deadlines, it would be nice if it produced this document,” Ste-Marie said.
“Thank you, Mr. Ste-Marie. I’ve spoken with the clerk, and we’ll chase it down for you,” Maloney replied, confirming a 5 p.m. amendment deadline the following day.
Toothless Clocks and Capital Flight
Even staunch corporate supporters of the bill’s goals warned MPs that its one-year project approval target contains loopholes. Conservative MP Philip Lawrence pointed out there is no clear trigger for when the 12-month clock starts, nor any real penalty when regulators miss deadlines.
“I’ll start with, first of all, the one-year time horizon. There is no clear mechanism to start the clock on the one year. They could have studies going back ad infinitum,” Lawrence said, warning of bureaucrats who say: “Hey, we have a plan to get on plan to get on plan.”
Business Council of Canada vice-president Michael Gullo acknowledged his members share those fears.
“There was anxiety around the front-loading aspect of how the bill is staged and what goes into a completed application before it is deemed to proceed to the next step by the regulator. The implementation concern is shared, I would say,” Gullo said, adding that while “cabinet directives have accountability issues on their best of days,” a deputy ministers’ committee offers a new way to blow the whistle.
Asked by Lawrence whether a special mediator who can only publish reports has any real clout—”if reports got the economy growing, our Canadian economy would be the fastest-growing economy in the world, which it clearly is not”—Business Council CEO Goldy Hyder agreed.
“Your concern, however, is well founded, because our whole point to this message on optionality is that if such a thing were to happen, the government should have a lever to pull to say: “We’re not going along with that. We’re going to intervene because there’s a national interest here that supersedes what’s taking place.”” Hyder said.
Liberal MP Parm Bains asked how the bill helps exporters pivot amid “unjustified tariffs,” prompting Hyder to point to a “very difficult decade when we saw $1 trillion leave the country,” warning earlier: “If these are not on offer, capital won’t form.”
A 5:1 Indigenous Capital Gap
Tim Laronde, senior adviser to the First Nations Major Projects Coalition representing more than 210 First Nations, warned that fast approvals without Indigenous equity and funded capacity will backfire.
“We welcome the doubling of the federal indigenous loan guarantee program to $10 billion, but with roughly $630 billion in major energy, mining and forestry investment planned over the next decade, we estimate that first nations’ equity will need to be $50 billion or more in guarantee support. That is a 5:1 gap,” Laronde testified.
“Without those conditions, the bill risks producing approvals that come quickly but projects that are slow to build because they end up being contested,” he warned.
When Ste-Marie asked Gullo why the bill fails to codify Indigenous business co-creation—”Is that something you think could have been included to make the bill more acceptable to first nations?”—Gullo replied: “Frankly, I think it’s a very difficult thing to codify in legislation.”
Meanwhile, Liberal MP Danielle Martin asked Laronde if the bill’s proposed Indigenous consultation hub would help his coalition’s members.
“I don’t think a national hub would work, but I would certainly be open to the idea of regional hubs, sort of like what we did in Yellowknife. We’ve also done this in Whitehorse, Yukon, and we plan to do this in Manitoba as well, because that’s the feedback we’re getting from members,” Laronde said.