Labour leaders threaten Charter challenges over expanded ministerial powers while farm groups cite massive rail losses.

OTTAWA — Canada’s largest private-sector unions recently put federal lawmakers on notice that Bill C-39’s overhaul of the Canada Labour Code crosses a constitutional red line and will trigger immediate court challenges if passed.

Testifying in Ottawa on Monday, October 26, 2026 before the House of Commons Legislative Committee on Bill C-39, Unifor national president Lana Payne and United Steelworkers national director Marty Warren argued that rewriting section 107 hands the labour minister a unilateral weapon to crush legal strikes.

“The bill is proposing to give the minister responsible for labour a superpower: the power to override rights, stop legal strikes and direct the CIRB to end a labour dispute and impose an agreement, not through Parliament but through a single minister,” Payne told MPs, warning that even federal government lawyers flagged potential Charter section 2(d) violations.

Opposition Questions Ministerial ‘Guardrails’

Conservative and Bloc Québécois MPs pressed labour witnesses on whether Ottawa’s claim of adding procedural guardrails holds up under scrutiny.

“The minister seems to think that the new changes in this bill to section 107 are guardrails. She also believes that the changes she’s made will lead to less labour disruption. What do you think of that? Do you agree with what she’s had to say on that?” Conservative MP Kyle Seeback asked Payne.

“What I can tell you is what I know happens at bargaining tables. The rules of bargaining, as I said in my opening, will change the behaviour of bargaining. If employers believe they’re going to get to a place where there’s a special mediator’s report or where the minister can intervene very quickly after a dispute starts, that will start changing how they act at the bargaining table,” Payne replied.

Bloc Québécois MP Gabriel Ste-Marie raised the same concern with Steelworkers legislative representative François Soucy.

“Therefore, my question is this: Wouldn’t the new powers encourage employers to wait for the government to intervene rather than make the compromises necessary to reach an agreement?” Ste-Marie asked.

“You’re absolutely right. We think that’s really the problem. Collective bargaining is built on a balance of power. If the employer doesn’t feel that there are consequences for refusing to negotiate or if it expects the government to intervene, it has much less incentive to make concessions at the bargaining table,” Soucy responded.

Bloc MP Andréanne Larouche then asked what concrete changes the Steelworkers wanted to see.

“In concrete terms, then, what amendments is United Steelworkers asking the committee for to protect the right to strike?” Larouche asked.

“We’ll start with the first one: We call for the complete repeal of section 107,” Soucy answered, adding that no other G7 country—”Even in the United States, under the very authoritarian Donald Trump”—grants a labour minister power to force striking workers back to work.

When Seeback asked Warren whether Ottawa’s frequent use of section 107 over the past two years had improved labour stability, Warren pushed back hard.

“Has that frequent use of section 107 helped labour relations in the country, or do you think it’s leading to more instability?” Seeback asked.

“I’ll just go. I don’t think it has helped at all,” Warren replied. “It’s taking away somebody’s right to strike. It should go to Parliament. It should be debated, and each MP should have to stand up and voice their yea or nay so their constituents can see how they voted.”

Liberals Tout Mediation While Shippers Cite Export Losses

Liberal MPs steered the questioning toward Bill C-39’s early-intervention tools and the economic fallout of rail and port shutdowns on third parties.

“Would you agree that measures encouraging parties to engage earlier in negotiations can improve the likelihood of reaching agreements without labour disruptions?” Liberal MP Emma Harrison asked Payne.

“Having these tools in the code, having early intervention and having a special mediator’s report that is transparent are all good additions in Bill C-39,” Payne acknowledged, though she cautioned against dragging out already lengthy federal bargaining timelines.

Earlier in the hearing, Liberal MP Caroline Desrochers pressed Canadian Federation of Agriculture executive director Scott Ross on what options farmers have when trains and marine terminals stop moving.

“I’d like to understand this: From your perspective, what other means do farmers have of getting their product to market if rails and ports are not available to them?” Desrochers asked.

“Simply, they do not have any alternatives. For foreign markets in particular, ports are absolutely essential. Even for the vast majority of producers that are shipping domestically, if you’re in the prairie provinces, as a prime example, costs and shortages in trucking make it cost-prohibitive to ship many of the commodities farmers rely on for their incomes,” Ross said, citing estimates that a one-week combined rail and port stoppage during peak export season could cost Canada’s grain sector nearly $540 million.

Business groups, including the Fédération des chambres de commerce du Québec, backed ministerial intervention powers and urged longer strike-notice periods, while the CFA asked MPs to make extended rail interswitching permanent immediately.

“Should this just be permanent?” Conservative MP Branden Leslie asked Ross on the bill’s four-year prairie interswitching pilot.

“Yes. Since day one, we’ve believed extended interswitching should be an ever-present reality for Canadian farmers to ensure the competition they need to be able to ship products effectively,” Ross replied.