Parliamentary witnesses clash over whether Ottawa should back Canadian CANDU reactors over U.S.-based Westinghouse technology.

OTTAWA — A sharp industrial-policy fight over whether federal taxpayers should bankroll homegrown CANDU reactors or treat American-controlled Westinghouse designs as equals erupted before parliamentary lawmakers.

Appearing before the House of Commons Standing Committee on Natural Resources on Monday, November 2, 2026 in Ottawa, Dr. Christopher Keefer, president of Canadians for Nuclear Energy, accused Cameco Corp. of creating a false equivalence between its minority stake in U.S.-based Westinghouse’s AP1000 reactor and Canadian-owned CANDU intellectual property.

Conservative MP Pat Kelly challenged Keefer directly on the fiscal cost of backing domestic technology after Cameco CEO Tim Gitzel told the committee earlier that the AP1000 deserved equal standing. "Is there room for more than one technology in Canada’s nuclear policy? If not, what would you say to critics who say that the AP1000 comes at no cost to the taxpayer whereas the CANDU is a taxpayer-funded strategy?" asked Kelly.

Keefer rejected the premise that private capital would build any large nuclear plant without government guarantees. "It’s precisely because the CANDU is a tax-funded reactor—and I’m talking over the last 70 years—that we have all the benefits I discussed in my speech, with IP revenues and a hyperlocalized supply chain that we’ve seen really thrive with the CANDU refurbishments. I would be incredibly skeptical of a claim that there would not need to be provincial or federal backstopping to de-risk capital going into nuclear projects," replied Keefer.

Northern Ontario Conservative MP Jim Bélanger questioned Cameco’s commercial pull toward American reactors given its massive Saskatchewan uranium operations and 49 per cent stake in Westinghouse alongside Brookfield’s 51 per cent share. "Cameco owns uranium mines in Saskatchewan. How could it not have a penchant for U.S. technology with that scenario and that dynamic?" Bélanger asked.

"Cameco fuels a global market. It fuels all of our reactors. It’s actually involved in fabricating fuel bundles for CANDU, so it sees a real benefit there. It’s absolutely the ownership stake in Westinghouse that has radically changed the direction it’s under," Keefer responded, adding that U.S. export laws still keep core AP1000 control in American hands. "I have huge respect for Cameco and what it’s doing by producing fuel and mining uranium responsibly, but I think we have to be careful of claims of equivalency between the AP1000 and CANDU in terms of national industrial policy and benefits to Canadians."

Provincial jurisdiction vs. federal purse strings

Liberal MP Eric St-Pierre pressed Keefer on whether Ottawa’s nuclear strategy properly balances provincial power over electricity procurement with competing corporate footprints in Canada. "Both CANDU and Westinghouse are Canadian in their own distinct ways. Given that electricity procurement decisions are under provincial jurisdiction, do you believe Canada’s approach should be supporting both reactor designs, and do you believe the government’s nuclear energy strategy got that balance right?" St-Pierre asked.

Keefer said federal policy leans the right way but stops short of shutting the door on rival designs. "I think the strategy got things broadly right with a focus on CANDU projects and exports. It’s not quite as decisive as I might like," he replied.

He warned Ottawa could end up subsidizing a foreign rival against its own intellectual property in global export bids. "You can imagine one day exporting an enhanced CANDU 6 overseas and being in competition with Westinghouse trying to deploy an AP1000. We could find ourselves in that situation. If we finance Westinghouse technology, we are disadvantaging our own technology and the greater proportion of benefits it brings back to Canadians," Keefer said.

Keefer also cited U.S. tariffs on Canadian steel, aluminum, and autos—plus reported Washington talks over a veto-wielding "golden share" in Westinghouse—as proof Canada must avoid foreign nuclear dependencies. "We must sustain our economic relationship with the United States through thick and thin, but we have learned that it is essential to avoid critical dependencies that leave Canada exposed to American political leverage. Luckily, we are insulated from such a dependency by our indigenous CANDU reactor technology," he testified.

Cost alarms and partisan jabs

Bloc Québécois MP Mario Simard questioned the economics of nuclear expansion altogether, pointing to testimony putting legacy hydro depreciation at $40 per megawatt compared with $110 for nuclear and $150 for SMRs. "First of all, I’d like to say that I have some reservations about the federal government’s strategy on nuclear energy. To give you a sense of those, let me make the following analogy: I feel as though we’re trying to buy a Ferrari when perhaps all we need is a Hyundai," Simard said.

Simard warned Ottawa cannot afford to bankroll rival reactor platforms simultaneously. "I fully understand that the government will not be able to do both. So, strategically, we will have to choose one technology and focus on it. However, I doubt this will even be possible, given that the government aims to build 10 new reactors by 2050," he said.

Conservative MP Jeremy Patzer took aim at the government’s broader policy shift, noting years of federal hesitation before embracing large reactors. "I’m happy to see that the Liberals have finally gotten on the boat with supporting nuclear. It took them a few years to get there, but I guess it’s better late than never," Patzer said.