Constitutional scholars and opposition lawmakers warn making Building Canada Act exemptions permanent erodes parliamentary oversight.
OTTAWA — A constitutional law scholar delivered a blunt indictment of Ottawa’s flagship infrastructure bill, warning MPs that stripping time limits from federal project-exemption powers edges Canada toward permanent rule by decree.
Appearing before the House of Commons Legislative Committee on the highly controversial Bill C-39 on Monday, October 26, 2026 in Ottawa, Université de Sherbrooke law professor Maxime St-Hilaire accused the government of dismantling democratic guardrails that opposition parties forced into the Building Canada Act just 15 months ago.
“Instead, it’s buried in a 243-page omnibus bill. That is not an accident. It is a method,” St-Hilaire testified, arguing that Bill C-39 deletes a five-year sunset clause and lets cabinet exercise extraordinary exemption powers even while Parliament is prorogued or dissolved.
Opposition MPs Press Overreach Claims
Opposition members seized on St-Hilaire’s testimony to question whether the Liberal legislation strips away checks on cabinet authority.
“The government is overstepping international best practices, then,” pressed Conservative MP Jacques Gourde during the opening round of questions.
“Absolutely, the government oversteps international best practices when it tries to pass off emergency powers as normal powers, when it doesn’t set time limits on them and when it doesn’t ensure, for example, that Parliament will continuously be able to control powers that don’t normally belong to the executive,” St-Hilaire replied.
Gourde escalated the exchange minutes later, asking directly: “Have we reached the point where we have a totalitarian government?”
“That’s not what I’m saying, but there is a global trend toward making emergencies permanent. Yes, I have seen a few totalitarian deviations from the current government, but I don’t think that’s why I was invited today,” St-Hilaire answered.
Bloc Québécois MP Gabriel Ste-Marie cited a newly submitted brief from the Barreau du Québec before asking St-Hilaire whether elected lawmakers were being sidelined.
“You said that this wasn’t temporary and that it was becoming permanent. You also said that when the law is circumvented, stricter parliamentary oversight is required. Here, however, the legislative branch and elected officials seem to have been set aside, and full powers are being given to the government, which governs without having to be accountable to the House. Is that correct?” Ste-Marie asked.
“The amendments that I had proposed and that the opposition passed set out that the exceptional powers granted by Bill C-5, under the Building Canada Act, could not be exercised when Parliament was prorogued or dissolved. The essence of that guardrail is now being ditched. Powers will be able to be exercised even when Parliament can’t provide oversight,” St-Hilaire said.
Environmental lawyer Isabel McMurray of Ecojustice echoed that constitutional critique later in the evening when Ste-Marie asked why a time limit mattered.
“Could you tell us more about the importance of putting a time limit on these extraordinary powers that make it possible to circumvent the laws?” Ste-Marie asked.
“When Bill C-5 was enacted, we were assured that these powers were temporary, but these powers were necessary to address the economic issues in place given the trade war with the U.S. By making these permanent, we admit either that there is no emergency or that the emergency is ongoing and our tools are inadequate,” McMurray replied.
Industry Demands Predictability Over Politics
Liberal MPs and business witnesses countered that Bill C-39’s one-year review targets and single-window assessments are overdue fixes for a permitting regime that has chased capital south.
“From the perspective of investment, how important is the time to a decision, whether it’s a yes or a no? How would a predictable one-year federal decision window change Canada’s competitiveness for capital?” Liberal MP Tim Louis asked Macdonald-Laurier Institute energy director Heather Exner-Pirot.
“We’ve seen so much capital flow to the United States because it does get deployed faster. You get a return on investment faster. Being able to compete with that is going to be a boon for our Canadian resource and energy sector,” Exner-Pirot replied.
Liberal MP Caroline Desrochers asked Fédération des chambres de commerce du Québec CEO Véronique Proulx whether the bill’s provisions requiring regulators to weigh technical and economic feasibility met business concerns.
“Does what we put in the bill address your concerns, or do you think we need to go further?” Desrochers asked.
“I would say that the bill addresses our concerns,” Proulx replied, though she urged enforceable mechanisms to keep agencies on schedule.
Still, Conservative MP Dan Albas cautioned that even Bill C-39’s proposed one-year clock contains loopholes allowing regulators to delay starting the timer or ministers to alter project terms midstream.
“Right now, regarding that completeness clause, proposed subsection 19(4), where the responsible authority gets to decide when you can proceed on the clock, do you think that gives the responsible authority too much power?” Albas asked Exner-Pirot.
“I think anything that provides that clarity for companies of what is completeness would be welcome,” Exner-Pirot answered, adding later when Albas proposed limiting ministerial alterations to objective grounds: “In our federal regulatory system, we have a bad habit of turning a blind eye to ministerial overreach when we think it’s a government that’s conducive to that overreach and then having to pay the price when maybe it’s a government where the overreach goes against projects.”