Canada Steamship Lines warns emergency foreign-vessel rules threaten domestic sailors and St. Lawrence Seaway safety.
OTTAWA — A proposed emergency loophole buried inside Bill C-39 would let foreign—and chiefly American—vessels bypass Canadian availability checks and operate in domestic waters, drawing rare cross-party and labour-corporate agreement to scrap the clause.
Speaking to the House of Commons Legislative Committee on Bill C-39 in Ottawa on Tuesday, November 3, 2026, Canada Steamship Lines director Guillaum Dubreuil warned that altering the Coasting Trade Act under the guise of emergencies threatens both domestic marine workers and navigational safety.
Introduced by Prime Minister Mark Carney’s government on September 21, 2026, Bill C-39—short-titled the Building Canada Strong Act—spans more than 300 clauses across over a dozen federal statutes to accelerate infrastructure approvals, overhaul trade corridors and amend federal labour laws. While Ottawa promotes the package as a catalyst for economic security and investment, it has drawn nationwide protests and intense opposition from across the country.
Coasting Trade ‘Breach’
Opposition MPs found common cause with Canada Steamship Lines, which operates 17 dry-bulk vessels across the Great Lakes, St. Lawrence River and Atlantic Canada. Conservative MP Dan Albas said witnesses across labour, industry and ports oppose the Coasting Trade Act amendment, known as clause 289.
“Mr. Dubreuil, you talked about the Coasting Trade Act changes as being unnecessary. I agree with you. We’ve had other witnesses come and say that this is a solution in search of a problem. Would you agree with that assessment?” Albas asked.
“I absolutely would. In all the discussions we’ve had with Transport Canada so far in trying to determine what specifically would constitute an emergency situation that is not already covered in the Coasting Trade Act, we have not found a satisfactory example. I would fully agree with that assessment,” Dubreuil replied.
Bloc Québécois MP Gabriel Ste-Marie noted existing law already contains fast-track rules when no Canadian ship is available. “This clause eliminates the need to check Canadian availability beforehand. Is that correct?” Ste-Marie asked.
“Yes, that seems to be the case, from what we understand. It would be possible to immediately use a foreign vessel to do the work instead of checking whether a vessel that sails under the Canadian flag and employs Canadian sailors is available to respond to an emergency,” Dubreuil said.
When Ste-Marie argued that “in an emergency, then, it’s better to rely on our strengths, our resources, our workforce and our expertise, rather than subcontracting those things to foreign companies,” Dubreuil warned who stands to gain.
“That is absolutely true, especially considering that the foreign companies that are geographically closest to us are American companies. They could therefore take advantage of the system to come and do more business here in Canada in what would be deemed emergencies,” Dubreuil said. Earlier, he urged MPs to “strike or amend this section,” calling it “an easy way to allow international vessels crewed by foreign sailors unfamiliar with our geography, our regulations and our reality to operate in our waters.”
Digital Trade vs. Regulatory Friction
Liberal MP Parm Bains steered the discussion toward Bill C-39’s supply-chain and port modernization measures, noting that Richmond, B.C., anchors a port network handling $1 billion a day and 40% of Canada’s trade.
“If the bill is geared towards improving our port networks and trade corridors, and towards creating opportunities for the expansion of our marine infrastructure, do you think Canadian consumers could feel the benefits of a more competitive marine sector?” Bains asked.
“It is a widely known fact that up to 80% of the goods we consume on a daily basis transit by ships, and therefore, they are loaded and unloaded at various port points in Canada,” Dubreuil replied, agreeing that port efficiency lowers consumer costs. He also backed Bains’ praise of the Enabling Digital Trade Act portion of Bill C-39, recalling that ship crews until recently had to fill out port paperwork “in triplicate.”
Yet Dubreuil flagged other friction points, noting CSL competes with U.S. shipowners on about 45% of its trades while lacking harmonized ballast-water rules, and said Transport Canada’s “near coastal” vessel class cannot even dock in U.S. ports, curtailing Atlantic trade. He also warned against proposed section 49.07 imposing deep-sea saltwater standards on the unique Great Lakes-St. Lawrence system.
Albas questioned whether Transport Canada’s proposed transportation projects office can cut red tape without statutory clout. “Even among divisions within Transport Canada, this transportation projects office that Minister MacKinnon is setting up is completely toothless,” Albas said, asking: “What would you think about having a one-window responsible authority that could coordinate and have some teeth to get all those things coordinated with some authority?”
“Transport Canada is generally seen as a regulatory agency, which means that their natural reflex is often to say “no” first and then evaluate a project,” Dubreuil answered. “The more we can strengthen that project office within Transport Canada and the more we can, as you mentioned, give it teeth, the better off we will be.”
Dubreuil also urged MPs to extend the marine strike or lockout notice period from 72 hours to 15 days, recounting a Seaway shutdown more than three years ago when “nearly 100 ships were at anchor because there was no room at the ports for them to take safe harbour. If a storm had hit at the time, the ships would have been at risk, as would the lives of the sailors.”