Assembly of First Nations and Hiawatha leaders say omnibus bill cannot be fixed by amendments.

OTTAWA — First Nations leaders are warning Parliament that no amendments can rescue Bill C-39, setting the stage for fresh court battles if the federal government forces its sweeping omnibus legislation into law before Christmas.

Testifying before the House of Commons Legislative Committee on Bill C-39 in Ottawa last week. On November 3, Assembly of First Nations National Chief Cindy Woodhouse Nepinak accused Ottawa of sidelining constitutional consultation duties in favour of corporate deadlines.

“Since then, it has become the worst-kept secret in Ottawa that the government plans to get this bill through by Christmas. We are hoping that all of you prove us wrong,” Woodhouse Nepinak told MPs.

Introduced by Prime Minister Mark Carney’s government on September 21, 2026, Bill C-39—short-titled the Building Canada Strong Act—packs more than 300 clauses across over a dozen federal statutes to speed up major infrastructure approvals, overhaul trade corridors and rewrite federal labour rules. While ministers pitch the bill as vital to economic security and global investment, it has triggered nationwide protests and fierce resistance.

No Amendments Offered

With the committee allocating just two hours to First Nations witnesses before wrapping up testimony, Bloc Québécois MP Gabriel Ste-Marie pressed the AFN on whether the legislation could be salvaged.

“Chief Woodhouse Nepinak, if I have understood your presentation correctly, there are no amendments that can be made to Bill C-39 to make it acceptable. The sections you mentioned have to be removed. Is that right?” Ste-Marie asked.

“The position of the AFN is that Bill C-39 is fundamentally flawed. We did provide a technical submission, in which we made recommendations for harm reduction within the bill, but we’re not putting forward specific amendments because we feel that it is fundamentally flawed,” replied AFN general counsel Julie McGregor.

AFN strategic adviser Graeme Reed noted that across all 250 pages of the bill, Indigenous rights protections are conspicuously absent.

“There is no reference to free, prior and informed consent anywhere in the 250 pages of this proposed omnibus legislation, nor are there any provisions related to upholding the standards of the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples,” Reed said.

‘Early Works’ and Regions of National Interest

Opposition MPs zeroed in on provisions allowing cabinet to designate entire “regions of national interest” and letting proponents begin “early works” before final environmental assessments or consultations wrap up.

Conservative MP Philip Lawrence asked Hiawatha First Nation Chief Laurie Carr whether the bill serves future generations. “Do you believe Bill C-39, as it is right now, will be helpful to the next seven generations?” Lawrence asked.

“No,” Carr replied.

When Lawrence asked: “Do you have concerns with the Alto high-speed project and the early works provision being used, perhaps, to the lessening of the rights of your people?” Carr pointed to real-world clashes on her territory.

“We are now speaking with Alto. We haven’t been overly consulted on that, and a hydro pole is never just a hydro pole,” Carr said. “When we do consultation, we can say that an area is a medicine area or a site and that maybe they should move over 100 feet. That is the importance of that. I can’t stress that enough. It would also save a lot of time and court hearings or judicial reviews on Canada’s part if we worked together.”

Liberal MP Caroline Desrochers sought to reassure witnesses that a proposed one-year assessment clock is flexible. “What seems to be lost, maybe, and I just want to understand, is that when you’re engaging with your members…is it clear for them that the one-year timeline can always be stopped at any point in the context of ensuring this engagement and meaningful consultation with indigenous groups? Do you think that’s clear for your members? That’s my first question,” Desrochers asked.

Reed disputed that First Nations hold any such power. “On the timeline stoppage, there is no specific provision that allows first nations to stop timelines. There is for proponents, of course, and there is at the discretion of ministers, but even that ability has been decreased in the legislation itself,” he said.

Conservative MP Branden Leslie questioned whether broad cabinet powers to accelerate entire regions—such as all of Manitoba—require strict limits. “Do you think we should put some clear guardrails around when that power can be used?” Leslie asked.

“The guardrails would be upholding the duty to consult in UNDRIP. I think the regions of national interest are fundamentally at odds with the duty to consult in UNDRIP,” McGregor replied.

Looming Court Challenges vs. Industry Assurances

Both Ste-Marie and Conservative MP Dan Albas asked whether the bill’s tight timelines and truncated committee study—compared by witnesses to Bill C-5, which passed in 20 days—would push First Nations straight to Federal Court. Ste-Marie cited nine First Nations court challenges filed days earlier against the Pacific Link pipeline, bringing total legal actions on that route to 10 alongside two challenges to the Build Canada Act.

“Do you think Bill C-39 poses a similar risk of legal action?” Ste-Marie asked.

“In looking at the law, the development of the law and the duty to consult in UNDA, it is likely that there will be many court challenges,” McGregor answered.

Woodhouse Nepinak warned MPs directly: “When bills like this are rammed through and first nations aren’t given that time to present, it just creates division. I always want this country to work—first nations want this country to work—but when we’re not talking at the table and the only time we ever meet is in court, that’s a problem.”

Business Council of Canada vice-president Michael Gullo pushed back later in the hearing against claims that faster timelines will erode constitutional duties.

“In Canada, there’s the rule of law, and the Constitution prevails. Our members, when we look at major project opportunities, will double down on every ability to meet those obligations. In addition to the constitutional requirements, we also have many significant pieces of legislation in this country around environmental protection. None of these will be skirted,” Gullo told Ste-Marie.