Beneath the Tarnished Silver
The figures swam before Lena's eyes, smudged ink on cheap paper. Another stack of invoices, another month barely breaking even. Her fingers, still dusted with flour from the morning's sourdough, trembled slightly as she adjusted the small, flickering desk lamp. The bakery, usually bustling with the scent of cinnamon and cheerful chatter, felt cavernous and cold in the late afternoon lull. Christi, thank goodness, was at her friend Mia's, spared the sight of Lena hunched over the ledger, a frown etched between her brows.
She traced the numbers, a ritual of dread. The cost of butter, sugar, the specialist rye flour that Mrs. Gable swore by—it all added up. And then there were the repairs needed for the old walk-in fridge, groaning like a forgotten ghost in the back. Christmas, with its implied promise of bounty, felt less like a celebration and more like a cruel, glittering test she was destined to fail.
A soft jingle from the bell above the door cut through the quiet. Lena startled, quickly smoothing her apron and forcing a smile onto her face. Arthur. He was as reliable as the dawn, always arriving just as the light began to fade, asking for the same, simple sourdough loaf. His heavy winter coat was dusted with fresh snow, and he moved with the slow, careful gait of someone accustomed to cold. His eyes, usually distant, held a flicker of something Lena couldn't quite decipher today.
"Good evening, Arthur," Lena said, her voice a little too bright. "The sourdough just came out. Still warm."
He nodded, a barely perceptible dip of his head. His gaze drifted past her, over the display of gingerbread men and star-shaped shortbread Christi had helped decorate that morning. A tiny smudge of icing sugar, missed by Lena's hurried wipe-down, clung to the glass. Arthur’s eyes lingered there, a ghost of a smile touching the corners of his mouth before it vanished.
"Just the loaf," he rumbled, his voice like gravel. He always carried exact change, a handful of coins he'd meticulously count out. Today, however, he fumbled slightly, dropping a ten-pound note onto the counter. It slid, a crisp green leaf, right to the edge, threatening to tumble onto the floor.
Lena moved to catch it, but he was quicker, his surprisingly nimble fingers snatching it back. A faint blush crept up his weathered cheeks. "Pardon," he mumbled, then placed the note carefully beside the loaf. He waited, patiently, as Lena counted out his change. She noticed the slight tremor in his hand as he gathered the coins.
A Thread of Holly and Doubt
Later, after Arthur had left, his departing jingle a quiet counterpoint to the street's growing stillness, Lena found herself staring at the gingerbread men. Christi's haphazard icing, globbed on with more enthusiasm than precision, somehow made them more endearing. She picked one up, the crisp gingerbread giving way with a soft snap.
Christi’s excited voice from earlier that day echoed in her mind: *“Lena, guess what I told Mia? Santa’s bringing me the biggest art set ever! And for you… a new oven! So you don’t have to keep fixing the old one with the… the sticky-outy bit.”* The ‘sticky-outy bit’ was the wire she’d twisted around the thermostat to keep it from failing completely. A new oven. The idea felt as distant and fantastical as a trip to the moon.
She sighed, setting the gingerbread man back. It wasn’t just the money. It was the weight of expectation, the pressure to make this Christmas perfect for Christi, to somehow erase the grey, muted memory of last year. The first one without Mum. Lena hadn’t even put up the old tinsel, the tarnished silver strands that Mum had insisted on, year after year. It felt like a betrayal, and yet, the thought of unwrapping them, of seeing their faded shimmer, brought a sharp ache to her chest.
The small bell above the door jingled again, this time with a different cadence. Lena looked up, surprised. The street was empty, the snow still falling in thick, silent flakes. She squinted, then realised it was the wind, pushing the door ajar just enough for the bell to sway. As she reached to close it, something caught her eye. Tucked under the door handle, just out of sight unless you were looking, was a small, crudely wrapped package.
It was tied with a length of rough twine, the brown paper bag it was made from slightly damp from the snow. No name. No card. Just a small, lumpy parcel. Curiosity warred with a prickle of unease. Who would leave something like this? It wasn't the kind of town where you found mystery packages. She picked it up, feeling its unexpected weight.
A Warmth Against the Cold
Back behind the counter, Lena slowly unwrapped it. Inside, nestled amongst some dry pine needles, was a small, perfectly carved wooden bird. A robin, she realised, its breast painted a dull, realistic red, its tiny eyes two pinpricks of black. It was beautifully crafted, the grain of the wood visible beneath the thin layer of paint, obviously handmade. And beneath the robin, nestled in the pine, was a crisp five-pound note, folded carefully into a square.
She stared at the note, then at the robin. The five pounds wouldn't fix the fridge, wouldn't buy a new oven, but it was… something. A gesture. A kindness. Her gaze drifted to the window, watching the snow continue its gentle descent. It was a silent, anonymous act, a small flicker of warmth in the encroaching cold. She thought of Arthur, his fumbling hands, the way his eyes had lingered on Christi's gingerbread men. Had it been him?
A wave of emotion washed over her, a strange mix of gratitude and a tightness in her throat she hadn't expected. It wasn't just the money, or the bird. It was the acknowledgement. The unspoken understanding that sometimes, in the bleak midwinter, a small, quiet act of noticing was worth more than any grand gesture. The robin felt warm in her palm, its tiny wooden heart beating a silent rhythm against her skin.
She carefully placed the robin on the shelf next to the till, where it could watch over the shop. The five-pound note she tucked into her apron pocket, a talisman against the encroaching anxiety. The numbers on the ledger didn't change, the fridge still groaned, but something inside her shifted. A small, resilient spark. Christmas was coming, whether she was ready or not. And maybe, just maybe, that was enough. Maybe the magic wasn't in grand displays, but in the quiet, unexpected moments that found their way through the cracks.
She thought of Christi, her innocent, unwavering belief. The kind of belief that demanded a certain amount of hope, even when hope felt like a luxury. Lena leaned against the counter, the smell of old coffee and fresh snow filling her lungs. The town outside lay hushed, a pristine white canvas, and for a fleeting moment, the weight on her shoulders felt a little lighter, as if the falling snow had absorbed some of the burden. The air still held a sharp bite, but the thought of the little wooden bird, watching from the shelf, brought a peculiar, quiet comfort.
She traced the smooth, cool wood of the counter with a fingertip. It would be a long winter. Hard. But maybe, just maybe, they would make it through. And perhaps, even in the coldest parts, there would still be small, unexpected pockets of warmth. She closed her eyes for a moment, letting the silence of the shop wash over her, a quiet reprieve. The world beyond the frosted glass felt both immense and intimately close, and she was just a small part of it, trying to keep her own fragile flame alight.
Unfinished Tales and Fun Short Stories to Read
Beneath the Tarnished Silver is an unfinished fragment from the Unfinished Tales and Random Short Stories collection, an experimental, creative research project by The Arts Incubator Winnipeg and the Art Borups Corners Storytelling clubs. Each chapter is a unique interdisciplinary arts and narrative storytelling experiment, born from a collaboration between artists and generative AI, designed to explore the boundaries of creative writing, automation, and storytelling. The project was made possible with funding and support from the Ontario Arts Council Multi and Inter-Arts Projects program and the Government of Ontario.
By design, these stories have no beginning and no end. Many stories are fictional, but many others are not. They are snapshots from worlds that never fully exist, inviting you to imagine what comes before and what happens next. We had fun exploring this project, and hope you will too.